my husband's favorite key lime pie

by Stacy

If you stress-bake, raise your hand!

Last week, Key limes were on sale at the grocery store, so I bought two bags. You can also buy a bottle of Key lime juice (which I often do), but the limes make for a tangier, zingier pie. Plus, there is the martyr factor of juicing the limes yourself.

I make this simple pie in an hour, start to finish. It’s so easy! If you buy a bottle of juice, it’s also easy to whip together out of the pantry in case of last-minute potluck or company. Graham cracker crusts are quick and easy, too, requiring no space to roll out. Why would you ever buy one?

Graham Cracker Crust
Makes one 9″ pie crust

1 package graham crackers (about 9 crackers), crushed
3-4 tablespoons butter, melted
2 tablespoons granulated sugar

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Place butter in pie plate and place in oven until melted. I use 3 T for a crispier crust. More butter gives a chewier result.

three tablespoons buttermelted butter

While butter is melting, take graham crackers and smush them in their package. Add cracker bits and sugar to a food processor or blender and pulse until fine.

one package graham crackerscrushed graham crackers
crushed graham crackersgraham cracker crumbs

Add cracker crumb and sugar mixture to the melted butter. Mix until combined. Use a serving spoon to smooth out the mixture evenly in the pie plate.

add graham cracker crumbs to buttersmooth crumbs and butter

When the mixture is pressed evenly in the pie plate, bake at 350 for 3-5 minutes, just to toast slightly.

unbaked graham cracker pie crustbaked graham cracker crust

While the crust is baking, mix up the pie filling!

Key Lime Pie Filling
Makes one 9″ pie

2 egg yolks
1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk
1/2 cup Key lime juice
1-2 tsp lime zest

2 tablespoons lemon juice
2-3 drops green food coloring

Mix egg yolks, can of sweetened condensed milk, and lime zest in a medium mixing bowl. I like to whisk gently.

two egg yolkstwo egg yolks, whisked
add sweetened condensed milkadd zest

Oh, toss in some lime zest.

lime zestadd zest

Love these things.

key limes

I cut them in quarters and juiced them using my garlic press! Sometimes I just grab the bottle of juice from the fridge, though. It’s much faster. When juicing the limes, I squeeze them into my liquid measuring cup until I have the 1/2 cup called for by the recipe. Easy! Then I pour the juice through a strainer to catch any seeds or pulp.

strain juice

Then whisk all that up. Fresh juice tends to be a little more tart and tangy (which I like), but I often add a few tablespoons of lemon juice to mellow it out. I skip it when I use bottled juice. Some people really like their pie to be GREEN, and you could add some food coloring now if you are one of them. The green flecks of zest are enough for me!

whisk in juicekey lime pie filling

By now the crust is out of the oven and ready to go! Pour the filling in and smooth it out to the edges.

pour in fillingkey lime pie filling

Now bake at 350F for 15 minutes. Let cool and chill before serving, approximately 2 hours.

key lime pie

Serve with fresh berries and/or whipped cream. Or just eat it. You can’t really go wrong!

For a deep dish pie, use another 1.5 packages of graham crackers, 4-6 tablespoons butter, 3/4 cup lime juice, 3 egg yolks, and two 14-oz cans of sweetened condensed milk. But only if you have enough people to help you eat it!

{ 1 comment… read it below or add one }

C. White September 14, 2013 at 8:26 am

I’ve found if you whip up the egg whites and fold them into the recipe it makes a lighter pie. I have never cooked mine. The lime juice cooks the yolks. Give this method a try.


Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Previous post:

Next post: